The quote shows that If George did not have Lennie, maybe he could have a better life more than this because he does not have to take care of Lennie and he can live his life without get in trouble. Why does George kill Lennie in Of Mice and Men? He was killed by one gunshot wound to the back. So think about these factors and ask yourself the question if what George did was justified or. I shouldnt ought to of let no stranger shoot my dog. (Steinbeck 31). Go on, George. George was not a stranger to Lennie, he was actually his best friend. Accessed 2 Mar. WebGeorge kills Lennie right before Lennie is about to be caught by a mob of incredibly angry, and incredibly violent, men. They got ran out of Weed(the old farm they used to work at) for harassing a girl and not letting her go. George was a short man who traveled with an abnormally large man with the heart of a child who went by Lennie. Thats the thing I want ya to know (Steinbeck 106). Come on with me." However, the other side might argue that Lennie did not mean to kill Curleys wife, thus he deserves to live. Ask and answer questions. In Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, a main character gets killed by his best friend. In short, Lennie was killed for a reason, I see it as a justified reason. It was one lacking self-control. "I thought you was mad at me George" "No Curly would have hurt Lennie really bad, or he would have put him in a cage and kept him locked up. What does it mean to be justified? Come on, you guys"(48). If Lennie stayed alive, then Curley would have taken him and tortured him through immense amounts of pain for a long period of time. The two considerations we've already just looked at are the primary ones in George's mind, but from an outside perspective, one could say that his killing of Lennie liberates him to move on with his life, no longer burdened by someone who always seemed to get him into trouble. (Steinbeck 106). His act of killing Lennie is not considered criminal. Just imagine what would happen if everyone did that. Most people would choose their friend because they know how to choose the best of two options. It is true that George shot Lennie, but what some do not understand is why this occurred. In Chapter 1, what does George tell Lennie to do if he gets in trouble at their new job site in Of Mice and Men? Many people argues it was unjustified to kill Lennie because they could have escaped together, however Lennie is a nuisance and tends to cause trouble 1261 Words 6 Pages Good Essays Read More Since they had a special connection, George cared for him so much that he knew the right thing to do is to let him go and die happily, peacefully, with no struggle. That was his job. In the novella, Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck, Georges decision to kill Lennie at the end of the novel was justified. This was wrong of George and he is guilty because even though Lennie was accidentally, In the following passage, George is frustrated with Lennie and his previous actions, I got you! He didnt know better and what is right from wrong. I aint mad. He was a man that could have lived on to pursue he dreams, he could tend to the rabbits. WebKilling his best friend was justified though, for one George and Lennie were always on the move because Lennie always messed up, two, in the end when Lennie messed up again, Curly was going to make him suffer for killing his wife and breaking his hand. "All the time he coulda had such a good time if it was not for you (Steinbeck). Also by someone who cares for him, then someone who hates him, no matter how much it would hurt himself to do it. Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team. And he was too dumb to realize what he was doing. In the novel Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, George is completely justified in killing Lennie, and he is a man for others due to the choices he makes. Previously learning from the experience Candy had when he let someone else shoot his dog, George knew that shooting Lennie was his job to do. This is also where George finds Lennie and leads him into a false sense of security before he kills him, George shook himself again.No, he said. Why does George kill Lennie in Of Mice and Men? The hand shook violently, but his (George) face set and his hand steadied. George tells Lennie about the dream moments before he killed him shows that he cared. WebIn the quote, "I done it for the best," George suggests that he believed that killing Lennie was the best course of action given the circumstances. He didnt mean to harm, or scare her. Ill shootem in the guts. (SteinBeck 5) He said it himself in that quote that he is going to kill him no matter what. Lets get that place now (106). He understands that Curley wants Lennie to suffer as much as possible. George had done the right thing. Since George told Lennies aunt that he would take care of Lennie. Lets do it now. It They are farm hands who go from plantation to plantation working for the farm owners. More books than SparkNotes. First, George's killing of Lennie can be understood as a mercy killing. Also, George knew that if the ranchers were to catch Lennie, they would kill him as revenge for killing Curley's wife. In Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck, the concept of naturalism is portrayed through the experiences of Lennie, Curleys wife, and Crooks. WebIn other words, Curley's wife death did not cause Lennie's demise, due to the fact that Lennie would have got himself killed eventually by being unable avoid conflicts. Very sad as he tells this to Lennie just before killing. He could live a nice long life without having to babysit Lennie all the time. I'm going for my shotgun. Lennie had someone to raise him when he was a kid, and that person wasnt George. This was the same with George and Lennie. Justice! Les go now. He turned suspiciously on George( Steinbeck 98). Im going for my shotgun. He has done it without knowing how strong of himself. Lennie can not live a normal life, he would be unhappy to never get his dream or what he wants. Lennie is worthless, because he does. He does this for a few different reasons. In the first chapter of Of Mice and Men, what does George say to Lennie about how his life could be better without him? Another quote that shows why George is just in killing Lennie because of him being a liability is "You gonna give me that mouse or do I have to sock you?" George did the right thing by killing Lennie because it was the best thing for Lennie and for everyone else. Therefore, this quote tells us that George doesnt want to kill Lennie, but he feels as if he needs to. Love. Curley even mentions that he wants to shoot Lennie in the gut, which indicates that Lennie would endure an extremely painful death. What quotes show that Crooks is lonely in Of Mice and Menby John Steinbeck? Another quote that shows Lennies punishment of a mentality is "If you don' want me I can g off, One quote that supports my thesis is God youre a lot of trouble said George I could get along so easily and nice if I didnt have you on my tail and maybe even have a girl. The reason George blows up on Lennie like this is because George could have his life be so much more easier and they have just got chase out of their hometown because of Lennie grabbing onto a girls dress because it was so soft and because of his mental illness he holds on and keeps holding tighter. Even though Lennies idea isnt helping much, he sees it as the, Partners in Crime WebIn Of Mice and Men, George is not legally justified in killing Lennie because his act would be perceived by officials of the law as murder. George is going to regret this in his future. XqrN3; :QbwO_q_=3I8HYNkvG{(vEl[K/QIE0DK*>8!K0 Lennie did not mean to kill them on purpose. However Lennie is going to die in someday and It is better choice if Lennie gets killed by George not the other. From the day that Lennies Aunt Clara died and from the day George took Lennie in as a friend George was always there for him. Lennie shouldn't have been shot, and it pained Lennie especially since he was the one forced to do so. WebOf Mice And Men Quotes And Analysis 586 Words | 3 Pages he won 't have fear or sadness in his heart. As Curley's lynch mob is approaching, George holds a gun to Lennie's head as he retells their dream scenario one last time before killing Lennie.1: George's decision to shoot Lennie in the back of the head is justified by the fact that Lennie would suffer more if Curley's lynch mob were to capture him. Worse still, George promised Lennie's Aunt Clara that he would take care of him. cousin. WebNars albatross - Der TOP-Favorit unserer Produkttester. They make a little stake an then they blow it. In the Bible of Christians , it says that ''You should not kill or harm anyone in any way''. George and Lennie were best friends, and have been since they were little. Killing Lennie is justified throughout the book Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck because if George did not kill Lennie, then Lennie wouldve had a slow, painful death, due to the fact the Curly is furious at Lennie for murdering his wife. Lennie was Georges only family and George wants Lennie to know that before he kills him. Got kinda used to him(Steinbeck 40). Get professional help and free up your time for more important things. Accessed 2 Mar. George and Lennie had already run from one place because of Lennies actions, and now they had to be on the run again. George is not guilty because he had carried out justice against Lennies crimes, would be found justified. George had to decide whether or not he would kill Lennie mercifully, or let the rest of the worker's murder him. In Of Mice and Men, how and why does Lennie kill Curley's wife? The hand shook violently, but his face set and his hand steadied This shows that George can get the job done if the situation needs be. I'm going for my shotgun. Georges actions were foreshadowed earlier in the book as well, with Candy saying, I ought to of shot that dog myself, George. What does the title Of Mice and Men mean? ", (John Steinbeck, 1973, p.58), this really impacted Georges decision on giving someone else the ability to shoot him. He doesn't know his own strength, and he doesn't know when to stop once he touches a person. WebLennie---if you jus happen to get in trouble like you always done before, I want you to come right here an hide in the brushHide in the brush till I come for you (15). In the text it mentions that,George shivered and looked at the gun. Lennie and George have a special bond because George takes care of Lennie, who has a mental disability. George doesnt want to kill Lennie, but he feels like has to. Should George have murdered Lennie? George and Lennie were best friends, and have been since they were little. He should kill Lennie because Lennie cannot control his mind because of his mental problem even he did not mean to do the thing that he have done but George might have the better life If he did not have to take care of Lennie and at last if George did not kill Lennie, Curley will shoot Lennie. Should George have murdered Lennie? A piece of text from the book Of Mice and Men says that, Guys like us got no family. By Lennie saying this the reader is really depicting how mentally unaware this man is of his power by squishing a rabbits head with his own fingers. }ksw \ %|SEJdfD:+`@A George should have killed Lennie because worse things would have awaited him if he went to trial. eNotes Editorial, 24 Dec. 2017, https://www.enotes.com/homework-help/why-isnt-george-justified-killing-lennie-1126802. If they really wanted to they could have ran but then what would George do for the rest of his life? Although it violates God's law and Man's law could it still be seen as a justifiable choice. In the novel of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, the character George is justified in killing Lennie because of his actions caused by his disabilities allowing for a better life. Whether it is truly George's right to do this is arguable, but it can also be argued that there are no alternative paths for Lennie that don't involve an immense amount of suffering. George felt justified in killing Lennie because he felt he was saving him from a worse things. eNotes.com will help you with any book or any question. 3: Another reason George could be considered right for killing Lennie is out of his personal self-interest. However, no one has the right to end a person 's life, no matter what the reasons for it. George tried to help him at all times as far as he could, but still Lennie was still in serious trouble, that 's precisely the reason why George wanted to prevent Lennie suffering in the future because he realized that he could not live alone. Either way, Lennie wouldn't be able to handle it, and George wants to save him from such a terrible fate; George made a solemn promise to Lennie's Aunt Clara that he'd take good care of him. The act of George killing Lennie is. How Did Critics React to Of Mice and Men? In Of Mice and Men, how and why does Lennie kill Curley's wife? Aint you gonna give me no more hell? No, said George. Copyright 2023 IPL.org All rights reserved. George realizes that Curley is assembling what is essentially a lynch mob. Another argument that George is a bad friend to Lennie is the fact that George shot Lennie. I believe that if Lennie were to still be alive, he would lose Georges trust completely, but on the other hand suffer his entire life. They were best friends until he accidentally killed the wife of their bosss son. Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers. Let us know your assignment type and we'll make sure to get you exactly the kind of answer you need. The first reason why George is justified in killing Lennie is because Lennie is worthless like Candys dog. This exemplifies how if you are no longer valuable or had none to begin with, you are as good as dead. What quotes show that Crooks is lonely in Of Mice and Menby John Steinbeck? Found a perfect sample but need a unique one? He should kill Lennie because Lennie cannot control his mind because of his mental problem even he did not mean to do the thing that he have done but George might have the better life If he did not have to take care of Lennie and at last if George did not kill Lennie, Curley will shoot Lennie. This shows George was high-strung and could not believe what he undertook. Georges actions were justified because he did it for Lennie. Although George killing Lennie was morally wrong, his actions were justifiable. Third, George had to kill Lennie because lennie would have done it again. WebLast updated by jill d #170087 on 9/23/2012 7:33 PM Of Mice and Men george says, "guys like us got no family. Should George have murdered Lennie? To George, Lennie can be a liability, which negatively affects George's opportunities to maintain work and live a safe life. It was justified when George shot Lennie because Lennie made multiple poor mistakes, it was the only necessary thing to do. George does not want to pull the trigger, but he knows that the further consequences of Lennies actions will only worsen. I'm going for my shotgun. All I'll shoot 'im in the guts. In John Steinbecks novel, Of Mice and Men, two men, Lennie and George, travel through California 's Central Valley looking for work. Ill kill that big son-of-a-bitch myself. Latest answer posted December 07, 2020 at 5:10:16 PM. When George took Lennie, The book Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck, I am in favor for George killing Lennie. Yes, George killed Lennie quotes. An you aint to be trusted with no live mice. After all of the ranchers find out that Lennie killed Curleys wife, Curley states that he is going to kill Lennie, "I'm gonna get him. Carlson also becomes excited by the thought of inflicting pain upon Lennie, whom he suspects of having stolen his Luger. I never been mad, an I aint now. Latest answer posted June 05, 2020 at 1:01:08 PM. . In Of Mice and Men Steinbeck portrays the meaning of loyalty and loneliness by creating the feeling of love and loss between two friends, Lennie and George and an elderly man and his loyal senior dog. As you can see George is completely justified in killing Lennie because he is a. This is also where George finds Lennie and leads him into a false sense of security before he kills him, George shook himself again.No, he said. Even though shooting Lennie wasnt planned I think George knew it was going to have to be done sometime in the future because, Lennie ruins all of George 's chances of keeping a steady job. This quote shows that Lennie did not know his own strength. While Lennie may not be a violent person, at the moment he was being violent. Some people might think in the opposite side that George should not killed Lennie because Lennie did not mean to anything. However, George could have stood up for Lennie instead of killing him. Even if you were trying to help them would it still justify murder? Use T-accounts to record the transaction if it create revenues. WebGeorge is justified in killing Lennie because he is already being punished enough mentally. Lennie cant be liable for, This paragraph will be about the book Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck. I believe George should have killed Lennie because he has hurt people, cant control himself, and would have probably ended up in a horrible mental institution anyway. What are two examples showing how Lennie is discriminated against because of his disability in the book Of Mice and Men? He has done it without knowing how strong of himself. We know that Curley is a bully who was already angry at Lennie before Lennie accidentally killed his wife. With our Essay Lab, you can create a customized outline within seconds to get started on your essay right away. In Georges mind, it was either he got killed by Curley or went to jail, where he would be lynched. They aint so little." My proof is that George had to leave Weed, a nice town, just because Lennie wanted to feel a girls shirt. After all the anger that George has shown towards Lennie, he utters these words now so Lennie can die with a sense of peace. It's possible to say that George isn't justified in killing Lennie simply because it is wrong to take someone else's life. Lennie made many troubles this might be because of his disability, but this is the reason that he deserves to live. He plays with the puppy, bounces it with his huge hands and at last he killed his puppy by accidentally. Lennies violent acts are not to be blamed on George. However Lennie is going to die in someday and It is better choice if Lennie gets killed by George not the other, In the book Of Mice And Men by John Steinbeck, I believe that George did make the right decision to shoot Lennie, because of the relationship that they had. Later, after the other men catch up with George, the sadistic Carlson wants to relive what has happened to George: "Did he have my gun?""Yeah. George also knows that Curley is 2. Also, no one has the right to take the law into their own hands. If not, explain why the transaction did not create revenues. George killing Lennie seemed like the right thing to do. Even the best laid plans of mice and men often go astray.. There is other options other than immediately killing. The idea that people have both high and low-level goals is captured by the: Describe why efficiency is maximised in the loanable funds market when equilibrium exists. Accessed 2 Mar. George killed Lennie out of love because he knew Lennie would suffer if he lived longer. IvyMoose is the largest stock of essay samples on lots of topics and for any discipline. Killing Lennie is justified throughout the book Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck because if George did not kill Lennie, then Lennie wouldve had a slow, painful death, due to the fact the Curly is furious at Lennie for murdering his wife. They got ran out of Weed(the old farm they used to work at) for harassing a girl and not letting her go. The question arose that a life of running from bad things was not a life at all. He wouldve gotten in trouble enough if he was just talking alone with Curelys wife. The other side of the argument is that they were very close friends and Lennie never did anything to get killed. Lennie was going to die no matter what, George just decided to do it for Lennies sake. An' s'pose they lock him up and strap him down and put him in a cage. A dog, a pet, friends or family is what most people think of when the word is mentioned. Last updated by Aslan on 10/23/2012 9:16 PM And he was too dumb to realize what he was doing. 100% plagiarism free, Orders: 39 Thats a thing I want ya to know (Steinbeck 106). What happened that made George stop playing tricks on Lennie in Of Mice and Men? George thinks that it is best to kill Lennie himself instead of letting the mob get him. George knows that Lennie simply doesn't have the intellectual capacity to be able to handle the fate that awaits him. Even though the action was bad, George decided it was best to kill Lennie to protect him. Lennie had to be killed because he didnt know his own strength. ). Wilts, hes deputy sheriff. Get up on your feet. What is important here is that George says Lennie is a problem because he can never do anything for himself. Download the entire Of Mice and Men study guide as a printable PDF! At the very least, George would be thrown into jail and he due to his mental disability, he would not even comprehend the reason for his incarceration. By doing so, George was able to The dog can hardly walk and Lennie has some trouble moving around. The hell with the rabbits. 2: George's decision to kill Lennie is potentially better for society as a whole. And he was too dumb to realize what he was doing. Copyright 2023 IPL.org All rights reserved. There is a close friendship between George and Lennie, and George had carefully thought out whether or not he. 2016, https://www.enotes.com/homework-help/why-is-george-not-justified-in-killing-lennie-in-682646. George wanted it to be him instead of someone else. What quotes show that Crooks is lonely in Of Mice and Menby John Steinbeck? Order original paper now and save your time! which shows that George was trying to induce Lennie with good aspirations. My second reason is because George could live a much better life. Tricking your best friend? Latest answer posted November 18, 2018 at 7:17:30 AM. George Milton had to decide the fate of his closest friends life. When George hears Curley say this to all of the ranchers he wants to ensure Lennie will die a fast and painless death. WebGeorges decision to kill Lennie was ultimately for his benefit. One quote that explains Lennies confusion and mental illness is, they was so This is demonstrated by Georges understanding of the lack of alternate options. My quote from the book is, "Don 't shoot 'im?" George killing Lennie was a shock to readers. He didnt know anything. the killing is laid. Nevertheless, George feels he must get to Lennie before the others such as Curley, who seeks a terrible revenge for his wife's death as well as for his damaged hand. The other side is wrong because even though it hurt George to kill Lennie, someone was going to shoot Lennie anyways. Curley had told WebHow Does George Kill Lennie Selfish 959 Words | 4 Pages Lennie begged, Le 's do it now. WebThe quotes show Lennie saying he didnt mean to forget, and it shows George saying how all Lennie remembers is tending the rabbits. And then about a year later when Lennie accidentally killed Curleys wife, the whole farm was after him. With this knowledge, George ultimately decides that taking Lennies life is unequivocally the most merciful way to remedy the egregious situation. In chapter three Candy says "I ought to of shot that dog myself, George. He didnt mean to harm, or scare her. George is justified in killing Lennie because he is already being punished enough mentally. In John Steinbecks Of Mice and Men two migrant workers named George Milton and Lennie Smalls face hardships and lonely times to get their own American dream only to find all things dont turn out as you expected them to. That's all you ever can remember is them rabbits. (Steinbeck 3.) There are many different justifications one could come up with regarding George killing Lennie at the end of Steinbeck's novel Of Mice and Men. George killing Lennie was a good idea because Lennie was always causing trouble, which made George not be able to keep a job. Final act of care for Lennie. I only say George shouldnt have killed Lennie because Lennie was mentally unstable. It was better for Lennie to be shot by a friend than by an enemy. Let us know your assignment type and we'll make sure to get you exactly the kind of answer you need. Given the fact that Lennie has already assaulted a woman in Weed and accidentally murdered Curley's wife, there is no telling if Lennie would accidentally harm another person if George did not shoot him. Lennie should have been killed because he had broke Curleys hand, killed a puppy, and killed a woman. In the book Of Mice and Men, what is Old Susy's Place? The novel Of Mice and Men poses a moral dilemma; is murder ever justified? In Of Mice and Men, was George justified in shooting Lennie? He always said he could run away and not be a burden upon George, but since George only ever helped Lennie, Lennie struggled to grasp a reality of George not being at his side. Thats a thing I want ya to know (Steinbeck 52). To get a high-quality original essay, click here. "If I was alone I could live so easy." It also illustrates that Lennie can't make it on his own if he doesn't change his ways to have some type of value to George. Additionally, Lennie repeatedly places himself in difficult situations, and as a result, brings George into the circumstances. But once Lennie's in the hands of the authoritiesor the lynch-mobGeorge will no longer be able to make good on his promise. Latest answer posted December 31, 2020 at 3:22:45 PM. George tried to take away Lennies dead mouse saying Come on give it here. Lennie said Its ony a mouse, George. It kinda states Lennie doesnt understand that he is holding a dead mouse. Ill go right off in the hills an find a cave if you don want me. (Steinbeck 104) Lennie can tell George is upset. 2. We never know what could have happened, because George shot him. The novel Of Mice and Men poses a moral dilemma; is murder ever justified? This is a reason why George is justified in killing Lennie, because not only is he doing out of love for Lennie, he is doing it the nicest he can do it. For example, when Lennie runs away to hide in the forest right before the scene where George kills him, Lennie imagines a gigantic rabbit criticizing him, Well he[George]s sick of you, said the rabbit. This piece of evidence from the passage shows that Lennie did not mean to hurt Curleys wife. The other side is saying George shouldnt have because it wasnt right, and how George was Lennies best friend. Since Lennie killed Curleys wife he was a fugitive, and anyone who killed him is just. Well, I can go away, said Lennie. There would be complete chaos and disorder. While George and Lennie dressed the same, thats where the similarities end. But if the other outcome is worse, you're obligated/called to do the right/more humane outcome. Which is gross and not normal, but Lennie didnt know better. I wisht wed get the rabbits pretty soon, George. Le 's get that place now. George concurs, places the Luger on the back of Lennies head, and shoots him. More books than SparkNotes. One could justify that George has been taking care of Lennie for a very long time and he wishes to be the one who took care of him up until the end. Instead, made sure that he was hopeful and happy. Lennie couldnt remember anything, all he remembered was him going to tend the rabbits. Even though saying that Lennie is like a kid is a good reasoning to keep him alive, there is another reasoning. He has done many thing that make George get into trouble and It is better if Lennie has to die because of George shoot him not the other. George and Lennie were best friends, and have been since they were little. To start off, Lennie first Let us know your assignment type and we'll make sure to get you exactly the kind of answer you need. Killing Lennie is now the only means available for taking care of him; George probably wouldn't see it this way, but perhaps he's better off without Lennie, better able to pursue his dreams of owning his own ranch. WebGeorge made the heart-wrenching decision to kill his best friend, Lennie Small. One reason George should not have killed Lennie because everything that happened, was an accident. Even though George didn't want to have to shoot Lennie it was the right thing to do even if it seemed wrong. Slim knows that it is not George's fault that his and Lennie's "well-laid plans" have "gone awry.". I got you! In the first chapter of Of Mice and Men, what does George say to Lennie about how his life could be better without him? A different quote I found is when George and Lennie are talking, Lennie said I thought you was mad at me, George. No, Lennie. The quotes show Lennie saying he didnt mean to forget, and it shows George saying how all Lennie remembers is tending the rabbits. 'Course we 'll shoot 'im." The novel describes the lifestyle of two poor workers who have long-term plans to live a happy and successful life on a farm ranch. In the end George chose to kill Lennie. He was just scared from her screaming and kicking. Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers. I also strongly believe that if George didnt kill Lennie, the others wouldve done much worse things to him.
Car Accident On Sicklerville Road,
Elevenses Clothing Size Chart,
Who Is Robert Herring Sr,
Tennis Player Heart Attack,
What Does Dyfhm Mean In Text,
Articles W
